Chapter 2 - The Sister's Smirk

The cruelty of Evelyn’s words hung heavily in the bright living room.
Standing a few feet away, Barbara’s older sister, Clara, let out a short, highly amused laugh. Clara, in her mid-30s with sleek blonde hair and an expensive emerald-green sweater, sipped her coffee and watched the humiliation with absolute glee. Clara’s two school-age sons, wearing matching navy Christmas sweaters, were completely ignoring their cousin. They were busy playing with the massive pile of expensive, newly opened electronics and remote-control cars surrounding them.
Alina’s small fingers stopped moving over the broken plastic doll. She didn't understand why her grandmother was being so mean. She held her little tissue-wrapped ornament tighter against her chest, her hopeful smile entirely gone.
Barbara, Alina’s mother, was standing near the entryway. In her early 30s, wearing a cream knitted sweater, dark trousers, and brown ankle boots, Barbara had just walked in holding a tan purse.
The moment she heard her mother’s vicious insult, Barbara’s natural micro-expressions shifted from polite holiday tension to absolute, protective fury.
She didn't scream. She didn't cause a massive scene. Barbara immediately walked across the room and knelt down beside her three-year-old daughter on the torn wrapping paper.
With incredible gentleness, Barbara covered Alina’s small, trembling hands with her own, completely shielding the broken doll from view.
May you like
"It's okay, baby," Barbara whispered softly, kissing the top of Alina’s brown curls.
👉 What did Barbara supposedly do to make her own mother hate her so much?