Chapter 6 - The Cost of Finally Saying Thomas Wasn’t the Only One Responsible
Margaret asked the special committee to disclose her old instruction in its review.
Thomas objected.
“The current investigation is about Valerie and Halcyon.”
“The current investigation exists because we lied about the past.”
“We didn’t lie.”
Margaret looked at him.
“I did by omission.”
The old document showed that during the 2015 downturn, Margaret directed finance to continue recognizing certain developer receivables as collectible for one additional quarter while executives negotiated payment extensions.
At the time, she believed the customers would pay.
Some eventually did.
Several did not.
The accounting treatment helped Whitmore avoid an immediate covenant breach.
Thomas had signed the financial statements.
As CFO, he bore responsibility.
Margaret had pushed for the treatment.
She had never told Valerie that.
Nor had she told most employees.
The company eventually restated the numbers and paid additional lender fees.
Thomas resigned.
Margaret remained.
That history changed relationships immediately.
Valerie stopped returning Ryan’s calls for two days.
She also stopped speaking to Margaret.
Thomas moved from a hotel to the spare room at the home of an old college friend rather than accept Margaret’s invitation to stay with her.
“I’m not ready to play family,” he said.
Fair enough.
Whitmore’s board received the old records.
Harold Bennett asked Margaret the question nobody had asked eleven years earlier.
“Why did Thomas take the whole public blame?”
Margaret answered:
“Because I let him.”
“Why?”
“The lenders wanted management stability.”
“Meaning?”
“They trusted me more than him.”
“And you believed losing both of you would hurt the company.”
“Yes.”
Harold leaned back.
“Was that true?”
Margaret stared at the table.
“Maybe.”
“That is not why I asked.”
She looked at him.
“I don’t know.”
It was difficult to admit that a choice she had defended for eleven years might have served the company and herself at the same time.
Meanwhile, current finances began producing their own problems.
Independent advisers reviewed Halcyon’s offer.
The price was not absurd.
Whitmore needed capital.
Its newest automated finishing line had cost more than expected.
A major multifamily customer was paying slowly.
Pension obligations from an older plan remained heavy.
Valerie had not invented the company’s financial pressure.
Ryan had not invented the need for strategic options.
Margaret had been resisting outside investment partly because she hated giving up control.
Another uncomfortable truth.
Then the advisers compared Halcyon’s price to two preliminary indications from strategic buyers.
Halcyon was lower.
Significantly.
Valerie argued that Halcyon promised management continuity.
“Meaning you,” Harold said.
Valerie did not answer.
Ryan’s proposed employment agreement gave her five years as CEO if performance targets were met.
Margaret now understood the emotional appeal.
Valerie had spent her twenties watching her father disappear from Whitmore.
She had spent her thirties working beneath a grandmother who never seemed ready to leave.
Halcyon promised something Margaret had not.
A date when the company would finally be Valerie’s to run.
That did not excuse the proxy manipulation.
It made it understandable.
The special committee asked for all communications between Valerie and Ryan concerning the transaction.
Valerie agreed.
Ryan’s attorneys resisted, claiming marital communications and firm confidentiality.
Halcyon’s investment committee grew nervous.
Then one of Ryan’s colleagues sent a document directly to independent counsel.
It was an internal Halcyon memo.
The title was simple:
Management Risk — Valerie Whitmore.
May you like
Ryan had been telling Valerie she would run Whitmore after the deal.
Inside his own firm, he had recommended replacing her within eighteen months.
