Chapter 10 - RACHEL HAD TO FACE THE SLAP TOO
The criminal case surrounding Judith continued separately from the fertility case.
That separation mattered.
The embryo mix-up explained part of Judith’s psychological deterioration toward Ella.
It did not excuse chaining a child to a post, shoving her down, or forcing her face toward dog food.
Likewise, Rachel’s protective rage did not automatically justify striking Judith after Ella had already been pulled safely away.
Rachel’s attorney advised her to be consistent.
So she was.
She gave the same account every time.
“I saw my daughter chained and being humiliated. I pulled her away. Then I slapped Judith because I was furious.”
Not self-defense.
Not defense of Ella at that exact second.
Retaliation.
The district attorney ultimately treated the two women’s conduct very differently because context, severity, restraint, victim age, and overall behavior mattered.
Judith faced the much more serious allegations.
Rachel’s single slap became part of the record and was resolved without being turned into the moral center of the case.
Rachel still addressed it in therapy.
She also addressed it with Ella.
Not immediately.
Only when Ella was calm enough to talk about the veranda without panicking.
They sat together on the floor of Ella’s bedroom.
“I need to tell you something,” Rachel said.
Ella was arranging stuffed animals.
“What?”
“When I came outside and saw what Grandma Judith was doing, I got really angry.”
Ella nodded.
“You hit her.”
“Yes.”
“She deserved it.”
Rachel almost answered emotionally.
Instead she said, “What Grandma did was very wrong.”
Ella looked at her.
“But hitting her after I already had you safe wasn’t the best thing for me to do.”
Ella frowned.
“Why?”
“Because I want you to know I can protect you without losing control.”
Ella thought about that.
“Were you scared?”
Rachel’s eyes filled.
“Terrified.”
Ella climbed into her lap.
That was the conversation.
No lecture.
No attempt to make a seven-year-old decide whose violence was morally worse.
Rachel learned something from it.
Children did not need perfect parents.
They needed adults willing to make the rules apply to themselves too.
That lesson became even more important as they prepared to tell Ella the DNA truth.
Because Rachel’s greatest temptation was not physical.
It was emotional.
She wanted to hold Ella so tightly that no new family could reach her.
May you like
And she knew now that love could become controlling if fear was allowed to write the rules.
---
