Chapter 6 - Brenda Had Been Testing Mason Too
Brenda did not confess immediately.
But she had made mistakes.
Claire found one in Mason’s school lunchbox.
Three index cards were tucked behind the insulated lining.
Each had a handwritten question.
Who does Mom trust most?
Where does Mom keep Dad’s old things?
Does Mom talk about Caleb?
Mason recognized Brenda’s handwriting.
“She made it a game.”
Of course she did.
“What kind?”
“She said spies have to remember.”
Claire’s jaw tightened.
Military language.
Brenda had deliberately used Claire’s background to make the activity sound playful.
“What did you get if you answered?”
“Candy.”
“And if you didn’t?”
Mason looked away.
“She got mad.”
Claire stayed quiet.
Mason continued.
“Sometimes she didn’t give Ellie food until I answered.”
There it was.
The cold spaghetti was not an isolated act.
Food had become leverage.
Not enough to starve the baby.
Enough to frighten Mason.
Brenda learned quickly that threatening him directly did less than threatening his sister.
That explained her sentence:
You shouldn’t have gotten involved in this.
Mason had “gotten involved” because he refused to keep trading answers for Ellie’s comfort.
The baseball bat was not the beginning of his resistance.
It was the point where fear finally broke.
Claire contacted the detective handling Brenda’s assault.
They found multiple cash deposits from Caleb over the previous five months.
Small.
Regular.
Not enough to look like a payoff at first glance.
Brenda finally stopped pretending.
She admitted Caleb hired her.
But she insisted:
“He never told me to hurt the kids.”
Claire stared at her across the interview-room glass.
That distinction mattered legally.
Emotionally, it meant nothing.
“He told you to pressure a nine-year-old.”
Brenda looked away.
“He said Mason had something that belonged to the family.”
“So you withheld food from a baby.”
“I didn’t starve her.”
Claire felt every bit of military discipline inside her become useful.
She remained seated.
“You frightened one child using the other because you wanted information.”
Brenda said nothing.
Then Claire asked:
“Why did Caleb want to know whether I still locked my bedroom?”
Brenda hesitated.
That question finally frightened her.
“He wanted to come inside himself.”
“When?”
“Tonight.”
Claire went still.
The spaghetti incident had happened only hours before.
If Mason had not interfered—
May you like
Caleb was supposed to enter the house that same night.
---
Related Stories
