Chapter 4 - Marcus Had Already Been Taught To Doubt His Daughter
When Marcus searched his messages with Vivian, he began seeing something he had missed while living inside it.
Months of framing.
Elsie had another meltdown.
She says strange things when she’s upset.
She told me I’m trying to replace Caroline.
She lies when she feels cornered.
I think therapy is making her more dramatic because everyone validates her feelings.
You need to stop rewarding every emotional episode with attention.
Marcus’s replies made him sick.
I’ll talk to her.
She’s having a hard year.
Try to be patient.
Once:
She does exaggerate sometimes.
He stared at that message for almost a minute.
He remembered the context.
Elsie had claimed Vivian threw away a birthday card from Caroline’s sister.
Vivian denied it.
Marcus assumed the card had been misplaced.
Three weeks later, it reappeared in the kitchen trash when the housekeeper emptied a bag.
At the time, Vivian said:
“Must have been an accident.”
Marcus accepted it.
Another incident:
Elsie said Vivian had turned off the night-light after Marcus left on a business trip.
Vivian said Elsie had done it herself.
Marcus told his daughter:
“Sweetheart, sometimes when you’re scared, you remember things differently.”
Now those words haunted him.
Not because children never misremember.
They do.
Because Marcus had begun using uncertainty automatically in Vivian’s favor.
Confidence became evidence.
Tears became unreliability.
Vivian had slowly trained him to treat Elsie’s emotional state as a reason not to believe her.
May you like
And if the chip contained what Marcus suspected it contained, that training had not been accidental.
---
